The AMP’s chief economist, Dr Shane Oliver wonders if we are back in 2010.
Overnight there was another reason to ask that question with the second reading of US growth steady at an annual 1.8%, instead of the widely forecast improvement to 2.2%.
That’s got some forecasters wondering if the US economy will go on slowing, necessitating further help from the Fed, as happened a year ago.
I am getting a bad sense of déjà vu all over again. Or is it Groundhog Day?
Here we are in May and global share markets, after a reasonable start to the year, are fretting again about global growth on the back of worries about Greece, China, and softer global data generally.
Just like May last year!
Does this mean the global economic recovery is over and shares are heading off the precipice again? Or is it just another correction, as it was a year ago?
The long and widening worry list
After rallying into April, led by the US, global share markets have hit an air pocket over the last month.
From their April highs, US shares have fallen 3%, global shares have fallen 4%, Asian shares have fallen 5% and Australian shares have fallen 7%.
What’s more, commodity prices have fallen nearly 10% on average and the growth sensitive Australian dollar has fallen 4% from its 29 year high of $US1.10.
Its little wonder investors are concerned again.
While shares often climb a wall of worry, in the last few weeks the list of worries has become more worrying.
The European sovereign debt crisis has clearly not gone away, with Greece ultimately heading towards some form of default leaving policy makers unclear as to what to do.
There are ongoing strains in Portugal and Ireland, and a combination of soft growth and political problems making investors concerned about Spain and Italy;
The European Central Bank appears to be twitchy to raise interest rates again to combat rising inflation;
Japan has slipped back into recession – its sixth in 18 years – and the associated disruption to production is affecting global production chains;
Chinese growth is slowing at a time when policy makers are not yet prepared to signal easing, as inflation is yet to clearly peak.
This has added to fears about a Chinese hard landing;
Worries about monetary tightening in emerging countries are continuing;
Global business conditions indicators (such as the US ISM index and so called PMIs in other countries) are rolling over, albeit from quite high levels.
This is just as occurred through the June quarter last year;
There is concern that as the ending of quantitative easing Mark 1 in the US in March last year was followed by turmoil in the June quarter, the same will occur with the ending of QE2 at the end of next month;
The US housing sector remains chronically weak;
The pace of US growth slowed to 2% in the March quarter and this quarter doesn’t look much stronger; and
The US Government is up against its debt ceiling and the debate with Republicans in Congress about increasing it could become acrimonious and lead to worries that next year’s fiscal cutbacks will become even more severe.
For good measure, another Icelandic volcano is affecting north Atlantic/European air travel yet again, as it did last year.
And Australian based investors have to contend with talk of more interest rate hikes when much of the economy outside mining is struggling.
After sharp falls in recent days, shares, particularly in Australia, are a bit oversold and due for a bounce.
But until many of these issues are resolved or start to recede, its likely share markets and other risky assets will remain volatile and at risk of a further correction.
This is particularly the case given that we are now coming into the weakest period of the year for share markets.
Most of the gains in shares are seen between November and May, with the May to November period usually seeing smaller average gains, particularly in the September quarter.
Hence the old saying “sell in May and go away”.
Reasons this is just another soft patch
The key question is whether the long list of worries will lead to a return to recession and a new global bear market, or just another soft patch and correction in shares in the context of an ongoing recovery.
This is exactly the same issue as a year ago when a ‘double dip’ became the big concern.
Our view back then was that the risks had increased but ultimately the recovery will continue, and it did.
The same is likely this time around, with the latest correction likely giving way to renewed strength by year end.
Global monetary policy remains very easy and will now likely remain easy for longer.
The current soft patch if anything will ensure that the US Federal Reserve keeps interest rates near zero for longer.
If it intensifies it may also result in another round of quantitative easing (QE3).
Increasing uncertainty will also help prevent or delay further tightening by the European Central Bank.
It’s quite normal for business conditions indicators, or PMIs, to roll over after rising to high levels without sliding back into recession.
This is part of the normal ebb and flow of economic data.
For example, after peaking in May 2004 the US ISM indicator moderated for four years, without being associated with recession.
The strong US corporate sector is likely to continue to underpin fur
