Hunter Hall Battle Escalates

By Glenn Dyer | More Articles by Glenn Dyer

Talk about convoluted – the battle for control of Sydney fund management group, Hunter Hall (HHL) got even more complicated yesterday when Sydney based investor, Washington H Soul Pattinson (SOL) upped its bid by almost a third to $2.60 a share (from the previous $2 a share).

The move briefly lifted the offer price for the shares above the market after Soul Patts said it would pay the extra price if it got to 44% of the funds manager.

That move appeared squarely aimed at founder and former managing director and chief investment officer Peter Hall, who sold 19.9% to Soul Patts for $1 a share, triggering the current battle, and agreed to deliver the remaining 24.05% stake to them at the same price, barring a superior offer, which then emerged.

Mr Hall still retains that stake and barring a higher offer emerging, it will probably go to Soul Patts, unless Mr Hall wants to keep an equity stake in the expanded business. He would have a stake of between 6% and 7%, which is really not significant, especially seeing he triggered the original bidding war back on December 28 by walking out of Hunter Hall and selling the 19.9% to Soul patts at $1 a share.

The new bid price from Soul Patts is an 8% premium to the $2.40 a share offer from Pinnacle Investment Management if it clears the 44% holding hurdle.

But if Soul Patts falls short of that level the offer remains at $2 a share. Hunter Hall shares rose more than 4% yesterday to $2.67 as punters speculate another offer will emerge, possibly from Pinnacle.

The bid also remains below the $2.75 price nominated by independent experts for the Hunter Hall as the bottom of the valuation range for the stock.

A successful bid would give Soul Patts a second bite at Hunter Hall, whose board late last week endorsed a reverse, all-scrip takeover of Pengana Funds Management.

As Soul Patts already owns 37% of Pengana and it would hold 32% of a merged entity with more than $3 billion in funds under management, including $955 million coming from from Hunter Hall.

But the deal will dilute existing Hunter Hall shareholders, who will end up with just 27% of the merged entity, and the influence of the other major shareholders on the register.

RELATED COMPANIESTagged

About Glenn Dyer

Glenn Dyer has been a finance journalist and TV producer for more than 40 years. He has worked at Maxwell Newton Publications, Queensland Newspapers, AAP, The Australian Financial Review, The Nine Network and Crikey.

View more articles by Glenn Dyer →